Acuity Insurance

HQ
Sheboygan
1,727 Total Employees
Year Founded: 1925

Acuity Insurance Compensation & Benefits

Updated on June 09, 2026

This page summarizes recurring themes identified from responses generated by popular LLMs to common candidate questions about Acuity Insurance and has not been reviewed or approved by Acuity Insurance.

How are the compensation & benefits at Acuity Insurance?

Strengths in retirement design, healthcare value, and lifestyle perks are accompanied by concerns about slower pay progression, uneven base‑pay competitiveness, and location‑dependent perk utility. Together, these dynamics suggest a total rewards package that is compelling in aggregate but may feel less competitive for some roles or for employees who do not benefit from on‑site amenities.

Key Insight for Candidates

Benefits-heavy, retirement-first total rewards: Acuity reliably puts outsized, automatic contributions into your 401(k) and shoulders most health costs (often via HSA funding), while cash pay and bonuses can be more modest or routed into retirement. Great if you value long-term comp; less ideal if you prioritize immediate cash.

Evidence in Action

  • Employer-Funded 401(k) Stack The 401(k) SPD documents a 4% safe-harbor nonelective contribution plus potential fixed/discretionary nonelective additions, with internal feedback citing totals above 10%. Employees gain automatic retirement dollars that materially raise total compensation and compound savings, regardless of personal deferrals.
  • High-Share Health Coverage Published benefits summaries describe about 85% employer coverage of medical premiums and employer HSA funding that often offsets most or all of the deductible. Employees face lower healthcare expenses and higher effective compensation through reduced premiums and deductible exposure.

Positive Themes About Acuity Insurance

  • Retirement Support: Retirement contributions are described as generous and structured with automatic nonelective contributions that can be supplemented, creating strong long‑term value. Plan materials and commentary portray this as a standout element of total rewards.
  • Healthcare Strength: Health coverage is characterized as comprehensive with a high employer share of premiums and meaningful HSA funding that can offset deductibles. This makes medical benefits a strong pillar of overall compensation.
  • Wellbeing & Lifestyle Benefits: On‑site amenities at headquarters—fitness facilities, climbing wall, field house, cafeteria, and regular social events—are highlighted alongside remote alternatives. These lifestyle and wellness offerings complement core pay and insurance.

Considerations About Acuity Insurance

  • Stagnant Pay & Limited Progression: Advancement opportunities can feel limited, and raise dynamics are described as modest compared with peers. This combination dampens perceived pay growth over time.
  • Unfair & Opaque Compensation: Base pay is described as on‑par or a bit lower in some roles, with responsibilities at times expanding without matching compensation. These conditions create uneven perceptions of fairness across teams.
  • Perks & Wellbeing Gaps: Signature amenities are concentrated at headquarters, while remote and non‑HQ employees rely on alternate or virtual options. The resulting experience varies by location and may reduce the practical value of certain perks.
NEW
What does AI tell candidates about your employer brand?
Get your free AI reputation report today.
See AI Report
AI Report
AI Report

These insights are generated using AI and may not reflect internal data or verified company information. They are intended solely for general informational purposes and should not be considered a definitive assessment of the company’s reputation. If you are a representative of this company, and would like this page to be removed, you may contact us via this form.
Is This Your Company? Claim Profile