Sr. Payment Recovery Examiner

Sorry, this job was removed at 10:12 p.m. (CST) on Tuesday, Feb 24, 2026
Be an Early Applicant
8 Locations
In-Office or Remote
Insurance
The Role

Are you looking to make an impactful difference in your work, yourself, and your community? Why settle for just a job when you can land a career? At ICW Group, we are hiring team members who are ready to use their skills, curiosity, and drive to be part of our  journey as we strive to transform the insurance  carrier space. We're proud to be in business for over 50 years, and its change agents like yourself that will help us continue to deliver our mission to create the best insurance experience possible.

Headquartered in San Diego with regional offices located throughout the United States, ICW Group has been named for ten consecutive years as a Top 50 performing P&C organization offering the stability of a large, profitable and growing company combined with a focus on all things people. It's our team members who make us an employer of choice and the vibrant company we are today. We strive to make both our  internal and external communities better everyday! Learn more about why you want to be here!

PURPOSE OF THE JOB

The purpose of this job is to identify and pursue subrogation opportunities in the Workers’ Compensation claims line of business. The position exists to review claims with subrogation potential, analyze the potential for recovery, file claims with responsible parties and their carriers, and negotiate settlement in accordance with statutory and case law as well as pertinent regulations. This role will determine when litigation is a cost-effective method of seeking recovery and will keep the Workers’ compensation claims examiners informed of any significant developments. 

ESSENTIAL DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES
Manages all aspects of a complex claims inventory.

  • Effectively communicates with policyholders, agents, attorneys, and witnesses to gather information and provide the highest possible level of customer service.

  • Promptly investigates claims to determine exposure, works with appropriate experts and makes strategic recommendations.

  • Utilizes appropriate resolution tactics (e.g., mediation, negotiation, denial, litigation or offer) to proactively drive outstanding results.

  • Operates within the requirements of related state and/or the governing entity rules and regulations as well as internal claims handling policies and procedures.

  • Directs defense counsel throughout the litigation process in line with ICW litigation guidelines while monitoring legal fees and costs.

Responsibilities:

  • Consistently provides exceptional customer service.

  • Effectively collaborates with team members from various departments for project and process discussions.

  • Acts as a Subject Matter Expert for the department.

  • Makes recommendations for streamlining processes and adopting the industry’s best practices.

  • Ensures accuracy of data in claims system for compliance with applicable regulatory reporting.

  • Provides knowledge transfer across the organization.

  • Continuously seeks to improve technical skills by attending job related training and tracking current case law.

  • Acts as a mentor and provides training for less experienced team members.

Additional Responsibilities in Payment Recovery Unit/ Subrogation:

  • Investigates and gathers necessary information to evaluate subrogation potential of assigned claims.

  • Communicates with insureds to obtain information necessary for evaluating subrogation.

  • Directs and manages legal counsel to ensure timely and cost-effective litigation.

  • Attends arbitrations and/or mediations as often as workload allows.

  • Analyzes police reports, investigative reports, policies, construction contracts, and OSHA reports.

  • Pursues subrogation, recoveries and contributions vigorously and within statutory timeframes.

  • Maintains case lists and follows up with claims personnel and outside attorneys.

  • Summarizes and analyzes depositions and medical reports/records.

  • Maintains a calendar of important deadlines on cases.

  • Assists in preparing subrogation department metric reports.

  • Resolves claims fairly and equitably, acting in the best interest of the insured.

  • Reports all recoveries to ensure they are credited to the claim file.

  • Communicates effectively with other Company departments.

SUPERVISORY RESPONSIBILITIES
This position has no supervisory responsibility but will serve as a technical leader.

EDUCATION AND EXPERIENCE
Bachelor's degree from an accredited institution (or equivalent education and experience) along with 5+ years of related claims experience.
CERTIFICATES, LICENSES, REGISTRATIONS
Certification that meets the minimum standards of training, experience, and skill required. WCCA and WCCP preferred. State Workers Compensation License is required in some branches. Paralegal certificate from an accredited program preferred.

KNOWLEDGE AND SKILLS
Good understanding of Workers’ Compensation and Personal Injury Laws and jurisdictional restraints to manage subrogation claims. Ability to solve practical problems and deal with a variety of concrete variables in situations where only limited standardization exists. Knowledge of subrogation process required.

PHYSICAL REQUIREMENTS
Office environment – no specific or unusual physical or environmental demands and employees are regularly required to sit, walk, stand, talk, and hear.

WORK ENVIRONMENT
This position operates in an office environment and requires the frequent use of a computer, telephone, copier, and other standard office equipment.

We are currently not offering employment sponsorship for this opportunity

#LI-JM1

#LI-Hybrid

The current range for this position is

$68,481.25 - $115,489.01

This range is exclusive of fringe benefits and potential bonuses.  If hired at ICW Group, your final base salary compensation will be determined by factors unique to each candidate, including experience, education and the location of the role and considers employees performing substantially similar work.

WHY JOIN ICW GROUP? 

  • Challenging work and the ability to make a difference 

  • You will have a voice and feel a sense of belonging 

  • We offer a competitive benefits package, with generous medical, dental, and vision plans as well as 401K retirement plans and company match 

  • Bonus potential for all positions 

  • Paid Time Off

  • Paid holidays throughout the calendar year 

  • Want to continue learning? We’ll support you 100% 

ICW Group is committed to creating a diverse environment and is proud to be an Equal Opportunity Employer. ICW Group will not discriminate against an applicant or employee on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, ancestry, sex/gender, age, physical or mental disability, military or veteran status, genetic information, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, marital status, or any other characteristic protected by applicable federal, state or local law.

___________________

Job Category

Claims

ICW Group Compensation & Benefits Highlights

The following summarizes recurring compensation and benefits themes identified from responses generated by popular LLMs to common candidate questions about ICW Group and has not been reviewed or approved by ICW Group.

  • Healthcare Strength Multiple medical plan types (HMO, PPO, HDHP) are offered alongside dental, vision, company‑paid life/AD&D, and short‑ and long‑term disability, with a company‑paid EAP included. This breadth positions health coverage as a core component of the total rewards offering.
  • Retirement Support A 401(k) with company match is available, complemented by medical and dependent care FSAs and access to a 529 plan. This mix supports longer‑term savings alongside near‑term tax‑advantaged options.
  • Leave & Time Off Breadth Generous PTO and paid company holidays are part of the package, with some postings specifying around 17 days PTO to start plus 11 holidays. Flexible scheduling and paid volunteer time further expand time‑off flexibility.

ICW Group Insights

Similar Jobs

Trail of Bits Logo Trail of Bits

Security Engineer

Artificial Intelligence • Blockchain • Professional Services • Security • Consulting • Cybersecurity • Defense
Remote
United States
125 Employees
100K-200K Annually

Leader Bank Logo Leader Bank

Business Development Manager

Fintech • Insurance • Payments • Social Impact • Financial Services
Remote or Hybrid
United States
420 Employees
72K-108K Annually

ServiceNow Logo ServiceNow

Account Executive

Artificial Intelligence • Cloud • HR Tech • Information Technology • Productivity • Software • Automation
Remote or Hybrid
Addison, IL, USA
29000 Employees

MetLife Logo MetLife

Customer Care Advocate Disability Service- Omaha NE 7.20.26

Fintech • Information Technology • Insurance • Financial Services • Big Data Analytics
Remote or Hybrid
United States
43000 Employees
42K-42K Annually
Get Personalized Job Insights.
Our AI-powered fit analysis compares your resume with a job listing so you know if your skills & experience align.

The Company
San Diego, CA
955 Employees
Year Founded: 1972

What We Do

Welcome to the official LinkedIn company page for ICW Group, a leading national group of insurance carriers offering a range of products for businesses, including workers’ compensation and earthquake, as well as automobile coverage for individuals. Follow us here for company updates, career opportunities, product information, workers’ compensation industry trends, fraud prevention tips, risk management support and an opportunity to network with industry experts and peers. We deliver our insurance products through our independent agent and broker partners, and are a full-service group of companies—providing industry-leading claims, risk management and fraud investigation services. For more than 40 years, we have partnered with agents and policyholders to achieve fewer and less costly claims. ICW Group is headquartered in San Diego, and has branch offices across the United States. Learn more about our company at http://www.icwgroup.com

Similar Companies Hiring

Globe Life Thumbnail
Insurance • Financial Services
McKinney, TX
3000 Employees
MassMutual India Thumbnail
Big Data • Fintech • Information Technology • Insurance • Financial Services
Hyderabad, Telangana
Granted Thumbnail
Mobile • Insurance • Healthtech • Financial Services • Artificial Intelligence
New York, New York
23 Employees

Sign up now Access later

Create Free Account

Please log in or sign up to report this job.

Create Free Account