Manager - Central Claims

Posted 3 Days Ago
Be an Early Applicant
Sheboygan, WI, USA
Hybrid
Senior level
Insurance • Software
The Role
Manage a team of 7–9 inside claim representatives, ensuring compliant claims handling via hiring, training, file reviews, audits, and reporting. Oversee litigation defense and subrogation, monitor reserves and workload, grant settlement authority within limits, conduct performance evaluations, and coordinate ongoing training and staffing recommendations.
Summary Generated by Built In
Acuity is seeking a Manager - Central Claims to supervise a staff of 7-9 Inside Claim Representatives. In this role, you will ensure compliance with Acuity policies and claims handling standards through participation in hiring, training, regular file reviews and claim audits. In addition, this role oversees and/or handles litigation defense and subrogation claims.
 
Internal deadline to apply: July 30th, 2026
 
ESSENTIAL RESPONSIBILITIES:
 
  • Manages team for consistency of claims handling in compliance with the policy terms and applicable laws.
  • Monitors claims workload and pending for purposes of equitable distribution of work between all representatives within their unit.
  • Promotes our company customer service philosophy to our representatives and monitors for delivery.
  • Monitors daily reserves on all claims within his/her unit.
  • Provides expense information to the General Manager of Claims for adequate company budgeting.
  • Evaluates exposure and grants settlement authority within the manager’s authority level on claims over the representative’s authority.
  • Reports regularly to the General Manager of Claims on staff files and litigation files recommending reserve, settlement range and requesting authority in excess of his/her authority.
  • Communicates company policy, procedures, questions of coverage, evaluation of liability, exposure and application of law by meeting regularly with representatives and providing feedback.
  • Conducts annual performance evaluations and salary reviews.
  • Reviews Insurance Department complaints to ensure company policy & applicable laws have been followed.
  • Completes monthly report to General Manager of Claims outlining volume, pendings, productivity, seminars/training, personnel issues and miscellaneous items affecting the unit.
  • Ensures completion of audit functions as outlined by the General Manager and VP of Claims.
  • Recommend staffing levels to adequately handle assigned claims and provide excellent customer service to our insureds claimants and agents.
  • Conduct interviews for Claim Representative openings.
  • Coordinate and assist in the training of new Claim Representatives to ensure consistency of training topics.
  • Provide ongoing training and seminars for the representatives applicable to the related states and topics of insurance within their unit.
  • Promotes morale, team atmosphere and company pride within their unit.
  • Regular and predictable attendance.
  • Performs other duties as assigned.

EDUCATION: 

College Degree and/or equivalent work experience.

EXPERIENCE: 

Thorough knowledge of property and casualty insurance.

OTHER QUALIFICATIONS: 

  • Knowledgeable in all matters relating to property and casualty claims practices, policies and procedures.

*Acuity does not sponsor applicants for U.S. work authorization.* 

This job is classified as exempt. 

For this role, Acuity offers a comprehensive benefits package, including a generous 401(k) contribution, medical, dental, vision, life and disability insurance, paid time off, an Employee Assistance Program, and more. A full description of benefits and eligibility will be provided to candidates during the hiring process.  

We are an Equal Employment Opportunity employer. Applicants and employees are considered for positions and are evaluated without regard to mental or physical disability, race, color, religion, gender, national origin, age, genetic information, military or veteran status, sexual orientation, marital status or any other protected Federal, State/Province or Local status unrelated to the performance of the work involved.  

Acuity will include at least one in-person interview during the hiring process for all positions.  

If you have a disability and require reasonable accommodations to apply or during the interview process, including for in-person interviews, please contact our Talent Acquisition team at [email protected]. Acuity is dedicated to offering reasonable accommodations during our recruitment process for qualified individuals. 

Equal Opportunity Employer
This employer is required to notify all applicants of their rights pursuant to federal employment laws. For further information, please review the Know Your Rights notice from the Department of Labor.

Skills Required

  • College degree or equivalent work experience
  • Thorough knowledge of property and casualty insurance
  • Knowledge of property and casualty claims practices, policies, and procedures
  • Experience supervising and managing claims staff (hiring, training, performance evaluations)
  • Experience overseeing litigation defense and subrogation claims
  • Ability to evaluate exposure, set reserves, and grant settlement authority within manager limits
  • Ability to complete audits, file reviews, and regulatory/insurance department complaint reviews
  • Regular and predictable attendance

Acuity Insurance Compensation & Benefits Highlights

The following summarizes recurring compensation and benefits themes identified from responses generated by popular LLMs to common candidate questions about Acuity Insurance and has not been reviewed or approved by Acuity Insurance.

  • Retirement Support Retirement contributions are described as generous and structured with automatic nonelective contributions that can be supplemented, creating strong long‑term value. Plan materials and commentary portray this as a standout element of total rewards.
  • Healthcare Strength Health coverage is characterized as comprehensive with a high employer share of premiums and meaningful HSA funding that can offset deductibles. This makes medical benefits a strong pillar of overall compensation.
  • Wellbeing & Lifestyle Benefits On‑site amenities at headquarters—fitness facilities, climbing wall, field house, cafeteria, and regular social events—are highlighted alongside remote alternatives. These lifestyle and wellness offerings complement core pay and insurance.

Acuity Insurance Insights

Am I A Good Fit?
beta
Get Personalized Job Insights.
Our AI-powered fit analysis compares your resume with a job listing so you know if your skills & experience align.

The Company
HQ: Sheboygan, Wisconsin
1,727 Employees
Year Founded: 1925

What We Do

Acuity Insurance is a leading provider of insurance solutions, delivering exceptional coverage and customer service to individuals and businesses in over 30 states. With over $3 billion in annual written premium, the insurer manages assets exceeding $8.5 billion. Headquartered in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, Acuity employs nearly 1,900 people.

Similar Jobs

SoFi Logo SoFi

Senior Manager, Capital Markets

Fintech • Mobile • Software • Financial Services
Easy Apply
Remote or Hybrid
United States
4500 Employees
176K-270K Annually

Liberty Mutual Insurance Logo Liberty Mutual Insurance

Inside Sales Representative

Artificial Intelligence • Fintech • Insurance • Marketing Tech • Software • Analytics
Remote or Hybrid
8 Locations
40000 Employees
45K-85K Annually

Empathy Logo Empathy

Care Manager 1, Bilingual - English & Spanish

Fintech • Healthtech • HR Tech • Information Technology • Financial Services • Telehealth
Remote or Hybrid
USA
200 Employees
24-26 Hourly

Empathy Logo Empathy

Account Executive

Fintech • Healthtech • HR Tech • Information Technology • Financial Services • Telehealth
Remote or Hybrid
USA
200 Employees
160K-160K Annually

Similar Companies Hiring

Hanover Park Thumbnail
Artificial Intelligence • Fintech • Software • Financial Services
New York, New York
42 Employees
Kepler  Thumbnail
Fintech • Software
New York, New York
6 Employees
Onshore Thumbnail
Artificial Intelligence • Fintech • Software • Financial Services
New York, New York
60 Employees

Sign up now Access later

Create Free Account

Please log in or sign up to report this job.

Create Free Account