Description
Job Title: Senior Payroll Specialist
Location: Carmel, IN (100% On-Site)
Job Type: Full-Time
Why Join America's Auto Auction as a Senior Payroll Specialist?
At America’s Auto Auction, we move fast, take pride in our work, and create an environment where you can stretch your skills and make a real impact. Headquartered in Carmel, IN, we are a leading wholesale vehicle remarketing company with a growing network of auction locations nationwide. If you are a payroll pro who loves solving complex problems and supporting hard-working teams, we want to meet you.
Rewards for Senior Payroll Specialist
- Competitive starting salary, based on experience
- Comprehensive benefits package including medical, dental, vision, and more
- Matching 401(k)
- Generous paid time off
- Monday - Friday work schedule (early off on Fridays)
- Leading & fast growing international auction company
What You’ll Do as a Senior Payroll Specialist
- Run Multi-State Payroll: Process accurate, on-time bi-weekly payroll for a large workforce across dozens of U.S. auction locations.
- Handle the Complex Stuff: Manage off-cycle checks, retro pay, bonuses, garnishments, tax levies, and child support orders with precision.
- Own System Data: Maintain spotless employee records in Paylocity, handling new hire setups, status changes, and regular system audits.
- Keep Timekeeping on Track: Partner with local auction leaders to audit timecards, track attendance, manage PTO accruals, and fix discrepancies before deadline.
- Stay Compliant: Ensure strict adherence to federal, state, and local wage/hour laws, final pay rules, and tax regulations.
- Support Our People: Serve as the go-to escalation point for employee pay questions and self-service portal troubleshooting—always keeping records strictly confidential.
- Improve Processes: Spot bottlenecks, streamline workflows, and build custom reports in Paylocity and Excel for HR and Finance.
Requirements
What You Bring as a Senior Payroll Specialist
- Experience: 4+ years of hands-on, high-volume, multi-state payroll processing experience.
- Tech Savvy: Strong HRIS/payroll system skills (Paylocity experience is a huge plus!).
- Microsoft Excel: Advanced Microsoft Excel skills, including VLOOKUP/XLOOKUP, Pivot Tables, and large data reconciliations, are a plus but not required.
- Compliance Know-How: Solid grasp of multi-state payroll tax laws, FLSA rules, and garnishment handling.
- Soft Skills: Razor-sharp attention to detail, ability to juggle competing priorities under tight deadlines, and great communication skills to explain policies clearly.
- Education: Associate’s degree in Accounting, Business, or HR preferred (or equivalent experience).
America’s Auto Auction is an equal opportunity employer. Responsibilities and requirements may evolve to meet business needs.
Skills Required
- 4+ years of hands-on, high-volume, multi-state payroll processing experience
- Strong HRIS and payroll system skills
- Paylocity experience
- Advanced Microsoft Excel skills, including VLOOKUP/XLOOKUP, Pivot Tables, and large data reconciliations
- Knowledge of multi-state payroll tax laws, FLSA rules, and garnishment handling
- Strong attention to detail and ability to manage competing priorities under tight deadlines
- Strong communication skills to explain payroll policies clearly
- Associate degree in Accounting, Business, or HR, or equivalent experience
What We Do
American Auto Auction Group, LLC provides auto auction services, including automotive remarketing, live and online auctions, and transportation services. They are a leading nationwide automobile auction and remarketing facilitation company.








