Senior Claim Examiner I

Sorry, this job was removed at 04:32 p.m. (UTC) on Monday, Sep 28, 2026
Be an Early Applicant
Princeton, NJ, USA
In-Office
Senior level
Insurance • Financial Services
The Role
Manages complex workers’ compensation claims from investigation through resolution. Determines compensability, sets reserves, reviews medical bills, coordinates treatment and payments, negotiates settlements, manages litigation, and ensures compliance with applicable statutes and fee schedules. Communicates with claimants, employers, medical providers, policyholders, and attorneys while supporting and mentoring junior examiners.
Summary Generated by Built In
Overview

We are seeking experienced professionals to join our Workers’ Compensation team in two key roles: Senior Claim Examiner and Lead Claim Examiner. Both positions play a critical role in managing workers compensation claim files and ensuring compliance with state regulations while delivering exceptional service.

Responsibilities

Senior Claim Examiner

  • Manage complex and high-exposure workers’ compensation claims from start to resolution.
  • Investigate claims, determine compensability, set reserves, and negotiate settlements.
  • Serve as a resource for junior examiners and assist with mentoring.
  • Requires 5+ years of workers’ compensation claims experience and strong technical knowledge.

Lead Claim Examiner

  • Responsible for prompt and efficient investigation, evaluation and settlement or declination of insurance claims through effective research, negotiation and interaction with insureds, claimants and medical providers.
  • Maintains a solid understanding of AmTrust’s mission, vision, and values. Upholds the standards of AmTrust and the Claims organization.
  • Requires 3+ years of workers’ compensation claims experience and strong technical knowledge.

Responsibilities:

  • Thoroughly investigating workers’ compensation claims by contacting injured workers, medical providers, and employer representatives. Determining if claims are valid under applicable workers’ comp statutes. Communicating with medical providers to develop and authorize appropriate treatment plans.
  • Reviewing and analyzing medical bills to confirm charges and treatment are workers’ comp injury-related and in accordance with the treatment plan.
  • Ensuring payments for medical bills and income replacement are remitted on a timely basis in accordance with applicable fee schedules and statute
  • Answer questions regarding the status of pending claims from claimants, policyholders and medical providers.
  • Consult with attorneys regarding litigation management, settlement strategy and claim resolution.
Qualifications
  • MS Office experience (Work, Excel, Outlook)
  • Effective negotiation skills
  • Strong verbal and written communication skills
  • Ability to prioritize work load to meet deadlines
  • Ability to manage multiple tasks in a fast-paced environment

Skills Required

  • 5+ years of workers’ compensation claims experience
  • Strong technical knowledge of workers’ compensation claims
  • Microsoft Office experience, including Word, Excel, and Outlook
  • Effective negotiation skills
  • Strong verbal and written communication skills
  • Ability to prioritize workload and meet deadlines
  • Ability to manage multiple tasks in a fast-paced environment

Similar Jobs

Liberty Mutual Insurance Logo Liberty Mutual Insurance

Inside Sales Representative

Artificial Intelligence • Fintech • Insurance • Marketing Tech • Software • Analytics
Remote or Hybrid
11 Locations
40000 Employees
45K-85K Annually

Wipfli Logo Wipfli

Analyst II, Workday ERP

Cloud • Fintech • Software • Business Intelligence • Consulting • Financial Services
Remote or Hybrid
United States
2900 Employees
73K-98K Annually

Wells Fargo Logo Wells Fargo

Senior Data Engineer

Fintech • Financial Services
Hybrid
Iselin, NJ, USA
205000 Employees
100K-196K Annually

Wells Fargo Logo Wells Fargo

Consultant

Fintech • Financial Services
Hybrid
Red Bank, NJ, USA
205000 Employees
Get Personalized Job Insights.
Our AI-powered fit analysis compares your resume with a job listing so you know if your skills & experience align.

The Company
HQ: New York, NY
4,104 Employees
Year Founded: 1998

What We Do

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc., through its subsidiaries, operates as a multinational property and casualty insurance company. Founded in 1998 to provide workers’ compensation insurance to small businesses in the United States, the company now operates in three segments around the globe: Small Commercial Business Insurance, Specialty Risk and Extended Warranty, and Specialty Middle-Market Property and Casualty Program Insurance.

Similar Companies Hiring

Hanover Park Thumbnail
Artificial Intelligence • Fintech • Software • Financial Services
New York, New York
42 Employees
Onshore Thumbnail
Artificial Intelligence • Fintech • Software • Financial Services
New York, New York
60 Employees
Vega Thumbnail
Artificial Intelligence • Automotive • Insurance • Transportation
US
43 Employees

Sign up now Access later

Create Free Account

Please log in or sign up to report this job.

Create Free Account