***This role is onsite at our Roslyn, NY with the option for a hybrid schedule after the onboarding period. **
General Summary: The Law Offices of Benvenuto & Gaujean (B&G), a captive law firm for EmPRO Insurance, is seeking an experienced Trial Attorney to join its legal team. The Trial Attorney will be responsible for maintaining and managing a caseload of in-house medical malpractice defense files for all purposes up to resolution, including trial and settlement.
Essential Duties & Responsibilities:
- Draft and prepare pleadings and other legal documents
- Prepare correspondence to the Court, clients, opposing parties, and internal departments
- Respond to all discovery demands and comply with all court orders
- Maintain accurate, organized and timely case files and documentation, reporting, and compliance with applicable court rules and in-house deadlines
- Attend court conferences as required
- Prepare for and attend trials; conduct investigations and discovery in collaboration with Sr. Trial Attorneys and other members of the legal team
- Evaluate medical records, expert reports, and complex medical issues to identify potential defenses and litigation risks
- Assist Senior Trial Attorneys with trial preparation, including witness preparation, expert coordination, exhibit development, and trial strategy
- Conduct legal research as required, including preparation of memoranda of law and motions
- Attend depositions of plaintiffs, clients, and co-defendants
- Attend conferences with clients and experts
- Attend and/or present at intra-departmental meetings and/or for purposes of EmPRO presentations to insureds as requested
- Assist the Sr. Trial Attorney with trial preparation
- Collaborate with claims professionals to provide timely case assessments, exposure evaluations, litigation updates, and recommendations regarding settlement and trial strategy
- Work collaboratively with internal legal teams, outside counsel, and medical experts
- Perform such other duties as may be assigned, consistent with the attorney's position and level of seniority, such as providing guidance and mentorship to less experienced attorneys
Qualifications:
- Juris Doctor (J.D.) from an accredited law school
- Active admission and good standing with the New York State Bar
- Minimum of 5 years of litigation experience with depositions and trials, witness preparation and medical knowledge
- Previous experience with Mock Trial preferred
- Previous medical malpractice trial experience preferred
- Demonstrated continued interest in and commitment to trying cases required
- Strong understanding of New York civil litigation procedures and medical malpractice defense
- Excellent legal research, writing, negotiation, and oral advocacy skills
- Ability to evaluate case exposure and assist in developing litigation strategies while exercising sound legal judgment
- Excellent interpersonal and communication skills, with the ability to work effectively with clients, claims professionals, and colleagues
- Writing and work samples will be required as part of the hiring process
- Candidates will be asked to provide a list of trials previously conducted, including the venue and index number for each will be requested, if applicable
- Travel required to all court venues, including Nassau, Suffolk, and city venues
- Must be able to work onsite at the main office initially, with flexibility for a hybrid schedule once fully acclimated to the role and responsibilities
The actual compensation for this position will be determined by experience and other factors permitted by law.
Skills Required
- Juris Doctor degree from an accredited law school
- Active admission and good standing with the New York State Bar
- At least 5 years of litigation experience, including depositions, trials, witness preparation, and medical knowledge
- Continued interest in and commitment to trying cases
- Strong understanding of New York civil litigation procedures and medical malpractice defense
- Excellent legal research, writing, negotiation, and oral advocacy skills
- Ability to evaluate case exposure and develop litigation strategies using sound legal judgment
- Excellent interpersonal and communication skills
- Writing and work samples
- List of previously conducted trials, including venue and index number when applicable
- Ability to travel to court venues in Nassau, Suffolk, and New York City
- Previous mock trial experience
- Previous medical malpractice trial experience
- Ability to work onsite initially and transition to a hybrid schedule after onboarding
What We Do
PRIMMA, LLC is a wholly owned subsidiary of Physicians’ Reciprocal Insurers (PRI) and serves as PRI’s attorney-in-fact. It took over management of PRI’s operations as the insurer moved to self-management, providing operational support and services for the insurance organization. Its work supports PRI’s medical-malpractice and professional-liability insurance business serving physicians and medical facilities, placing the company in the professional-liability insurance sector.







