Director of Claims

Posted Yesterday
Be an Early Applicant
Buffalo, NY, USA
In-Office
125K-200K Annually
Expert/Leader
Insurance
The Role
Leads the Claims division across personal, commercial, and captive accounts. Establishes strategy, workforce plans, performance expectations, and professional development programs while overseeing complex claim reviews and carrier escalations. Partners with executive leadership, client service, loss control, carriers, attorneys, and clients to identify risks, improve outcomes, strengthen retention, and enhance claims capabilities. Drives innovation, team performance, stakeholder relationships, and alignment with organizational growth objectives.
Summary Generated by Built In

These are the fundamental responsibilities of the job:

  • Provide strategic leadership, oversight and development for all lines of Claims associates (Personal, Commercial, Captives, etc.) with a focus on exceptional client advocacy, proactive risk reduction, and effective team performance
  • Establish departmental goals, objectives, workforce plans, and performance expectations that support the Claims division’s strategic plan
  • Develop the capabilities of the Claims team through ongoing coaching, training, knowledge sharing, and professional development, strengthening technical expertise and ensuring consistency in claims practices and client service
  • Lead and oversee substantive claim reviews for large and complex accounts across relevant policy lines, leveraging claim insights to identify emerging coverage gaps, loss trends, risk exposures, and client needs, and partnering across Client Service, Production, Placement, and Loss Control, and Workers’ Compensation Claims Management to drive appropriate solutions and follow-up
  • Partner closely with Loss Control to identify opportunities for alignment, share insights, and deliver a coordinated approach to helping clients mitigate risk and improve outcomes
  • Use client feedback, claim experience, and service measures to identify recurring pain points, strengthen responsiveness, and improve retention and client outcomes
  • Remain current on emerging claims technologies, automation, and industry innovations, proactively identifying opportunities to improve efficiency, strengthen claims capabilities, enhance insights, and improve the client and associate experience
  • Act as a liaison between the agency, carriers, attorneys, and clients, facilitating effective working relationships; leveraging established business relationships in local markets
  • Attend industry events, seminars, and workshops to stay informed and identify industry trends and market changes as well as new products and services
  • Partner with executive leadership to align the department’s priorities with company strategy, growth objectives, and evolving client needs
  • Functions as a resource for the Claims teams, and for other divisions, departments and services
  • Maintain consistent and dependable attendance, availability and punctuality as required to effectively perform the essential functions of the position

Other functions of the job:

  • Attend and participate in all leadership programs, workshops and training sessions to build and maintain effective leadership skills; model professionalism and integrity while guiding the team toward shared goals
  • Expand and grow in your role when supporting miscellaneous duties as requested

Skills / traits that we value for this role:


Page Break

  • Minimum of 10 years of experience in related insurance property and casualty claims
  • Minimum of 10 years of demonstrated leadership of people, service, and complex stakeholder relationships 
  • Expert knowledge of Personal and Commercial Lines coverages and claims advocacy especially in GL, Property and Auto; as well as the ability to lead complex claims review and carrier escalation 
  • Property/Casualty License (all lines); insurance designations required; bachelor’s degree in a related area, or higher
  • Demonstrated executive leadership with a proven ability to inspire high-performing teams, drive business results, and lead through change
  • Strong strategic, organizational and execution acumen, with the ability to manage complex priorities across a dynamic business environment. Ability to drive initiatives with urgency and precision. 
  • Resilient, solutions-oriented mindset with the ability to lead confidently and effectively in a fast-paced, evolving organization
  • Passion for cultivating exceptional client and colleague experience while fostering a culture of engagement, accountability, talent development and inclusion
  • Exceptional communication and executive presence, with the ability to influence stakeholders, build consensus, and communicate clearly under pressure and through periods of change

A bit about Lawley! 

  • We are not a call center environment
  • We achieve success by building genuine relationships together, with our teams and clients 
  • We have secured almost $2M in additional Claims payments for our clients in each of the past 10 years!
  • We are a family owned insurance broker (70+ years!)
  • We are deeply committed to the communities we serve and love to get involved
  • We work hard and play hard!!! 

Why Lawley? 

  • Bonus eligible position!
  • Expansive Benefits (Medical, Dental, Vision—and SO many more) 
  • 3 weeks of PTO (prorated based on start date) AND a generous holiday schedule – available 1st day!
  • Company 401K contribution received starting Day 1 (for participants 21+ years old) 
  • Educational support, career development, and growth opportunities
  • Job Security (we’ve never had a lay-off, even during the pandemic)
  • Flexibility, including hybrid schedules! Business hours 8am-4:30pm
  • Comfortable, family-oriented culture, with an emphasis on work life balance
  • Unlimited Volunteer Time Off opportunities (so you can assist in serving our communities)
  • Fulfilling opportunities that align with your career path and our business needs


The compensation range for this position takes many factors into consideration including but not limited to: years of experience/training, skill set, and licenses/designations. It is not typical for an individual to be hired near the top of the range for a position as circumstances and location can vary in every hiring situation. A reasonable estimate of the current range is $125,000 to $200,000.

Skills Required

  • Minimum 10 years of experience in related insurance property and casualty claims
  • Minimum 10 years of demonstrated leadership of people, service, and complex stakeholder relationships
  • Expert knowledge of Personal and Commercial Lines coverages and claims advocacy, especially general liability, property, and auto
  • Ability to lead complex claims reviews and carrier escalations
  • Property/Casualty License covering all lines
  • Insurance designations
  • Bachelor’s degree in a related area or higher
  • Demonstrated executive leadership and ability to inspire high-performing teams, drive business results, and lead through change
  • Strong strategic, organizational, and execution skills
  • Ability to manage complex priorities in a dynamic business environment
  • Resilient, solutions-oriented mindset
  • Exceptional communication and executive presence
  • Ability to influence stakeholders, build consensus, and communicate clearly under pressure
Am I A Good Fit?
beta
Get Personalized Job Insights.
Our AI-powered fit analysis compares your resume with a job listing so you know if your skills & experience align.

The Company
HQ: Buffalo, NY
664 Employees
Year Founded: 1955

What We Do

Lawley is an independent, regional insurance brokerage serving businesses and individuals. It provides business and personal insurance, employee benefits, and proactive risk-management support, using a consultative approach to help clients protect their assets and navigate coverage needs. Founded as a local agency, the firm has expanded into a nationally recognized organization through growth, broader services, and mergers, while emphasizing trusted, long-term relationships with clients, carriers, and employees.

Similar Jobs

Advanced Medical Management, Inc. Logo Advanced Medical Management, Inc.

Director of Claims Audit & Delegation

Healthtech • Professional Services • Consulting
In-Office or Remote
2 Locations
167 Employees
160K-180K Annually
Hybrid
New York, NY, USA
2400 Employees
219K-287K Annually
In-Office or Remote
51 Locations
85 Employees
178K-223K Annually

Stretto Logo Stretto

Director, Legal Claims Administration

Legal Tech • Professional Services • Software
In-Office or Remote
2 Locations
409 Employees
140K-150K Annually

Similar Companies Hiring

MassMutual India Thumbnail
Big Data • Fintech • Information Technology • Insurance • Financial Services
Hyderabad, Telangana
Granted Thumbnail
Artificial Intelligence • Healthtech • Insurance • Mobile • Financial Services
New York, New York
23 Employees
Vega Thumbnail
Artificial Intelligence • Automotive • Insurance • Transportation
US
65 Employees

Sign up now Access later

Create Free Account

Please log in or sign up to report this job.

Create Free Account